Which Fingers-Free Pump is Greatest? (2024)- The Breastfeeding Mama

Utilizing a hands-free breast pump is the brand new option to supply freedom and adaptability for brand new mothers. The Willow and Elvie are each wi-fi, cordless, hands-free pumps and we wish to assist you determine which one is greatest for you!

Selecting a breast pump can appear to be a frightening job.

There are such a lot of breast pumps on the market and whereas many are similar- no two are alike. Which might make it tough when selecting which breast pump is greatest for you.

Proper now hands-free, wi-fi and cordless pumps have gotten an increasing number of standard.

And for good motive! They mean you can pump and never be connected to a wire, a cumbersome machine and so they usually supply quite a lot of trendy, modern options that each mama deserves.

When you have finished your analysis you’ve got in all probability heard of the  Willow Wearable Breast Pump Technology 3  or extra generally generally known as the Willow. And you will have additionally heard of the Elvie, which could be very related in perform.

Each the Elvie and Willow for the modern-day lady and are wearable, cord-free, hands-free, and wi-fi. The Freemie Cups aren’t fully cord-free, however they do enable for hands-free pumping with many various pumps.

Why select a hands-free breast pump?

Selecting a breast pump could make your life a lot simpler.

As a result of they’re cord-free you merely place the pump inside your bra and you may proceed to maneuver round get issues finished as any busy mother would wish to do.

Utilizing a hands-free pump is discreet, handy, and affords flexibility to your life. They’re transportable, small, and glossy trying making it simple so that you can carry in a handbag or diaper bag and retailer anyplace you select to pump.

How to decide on which hands-free pump is best for you

We now have finished the analysis and browse the critiques and compiled all of it collectively in a single place that can assist you determine which pump is best for you.

Each pumps are trendy, modern, and mean you can pump discreetly and with confidence.

However we’ve in contrast pricing, options, professionals and cons, in addition to their similarities and variations to information you on this processes of buying a breast pump.

PRICE

Willow

At the moment the Willow Wearable Breast Pump Technology 3 will price you round $499. They often supply a promotion to make it inexpensive – if there may be one occurring, you’ll see a picture beneath with the present supply!

That is the price discovered on their web site and on Amazon. 

Elvie

You should purchase the Elvie on their web site for $499 for a double or $279 for a single. You may as well buy it on Aeroflow, together with checking your insurance coverage protection for it.

You may as well buy on Amazon for a similar costs.

What’s Included?

Willow

• 2 Willow Pumps (one for both sides)
• 2 Flanges (24 or 27 – 21mm is offered individually)
• 2 ‘Flextubes’
• 1 Charger
• 1 Pack of 24 4 oz Milk Baggage
• 2 Cleansing Brushes

Elvie

• 1 Hub
• 2 Bottles (5oz/150ml, BPA free)
• 1 Breast Protect (24mm)
• 1 Breast Protect (28mm)
• 2 Valves
• 2 Spouts
• 2 Seals
• 2 Storage Lids
• 2 Bra Adjusters
• 1 USB Charging Cable
• 1 Carry Bag
• Directions for Use

Additionally they promote extras and add-ons that yow will discover right here.

Options

Willow

• Sensible options for extra consolation and output. The Sensible Know-how responds to your physique and maintains suction enabling mobility with out spilling.
• Milk is pumped into the spill-proof disposable assortment and storage bag reusable container within the pump
• Spill proof
• No loud sucking sounds
• No exterior tubes, cords, or awkward bottles
• Monitor quantity, view historical past, and obtain personalised suggestions with the Willow App
• Produces 20% extra milk than common breast pumps
• Willow affords Flanges and Milk Container equipment in measurement 21mm, 24mm & 27mm

Elvie

• It’s wearable, small and light-weight weight and matches completely in any bra.
• You’ll be able to join it to the free app to watch milk quantity in actual time, monitor pumping historical past for every breast and management the pump remotely.
• Consists of 7 depth pumping suction settings
• Costs in 2 hours by way of micro-USB
• Made with BPA free, dishwasher secure plastic
• Comes with 3 Breast Protect sizes (2 included within the field)
• Has 2 phases: Stimulation and Expression modes- robotically switches from Stimulation into Expression mode when it detects let-down and can pause when the bottle is full.
• Comes with bra adjusters that can assist you get pleasure from pumping in consolation along with your current nursing bras.
• The amassing luggage are within the breast cup itself, so there’s little or no visibility or bodily entry.

PROS

Willow

• It’s quiet
• It’s simple to wash
• You’ll be able to take it anyplace and pump anyplace
• It’s discreet- you might be pumping and nobody will even know
• Spill-proof
• Components are dishwasher secure
• There are seven ranges of suction with two new decrease stage settings in addition to a brand new sensitivity setting. 
• BPA Free
• It holds simply over 4 ounces of milk and you may put them straight into the fridge or freezer- with out spilling!
• Baggage match properly into the fridge and freezer- a lot better than cumbersome bottles
• Made for all breast sizes together with G and H bra cups
• No particular bra needed- however is is really helpful to put on a full-coverage nursing bra that’s stretchy and has a flap- keep away from underwire and padded bras

Elvie

• It’s hands-free, wire free
• Wearable
• Silent- it doesn’t make quite a lot of noise!
• You’ll be able to join it to an app
• Solely 5 components to wash
• Solely takes seconds to assemble
• Can buy with an FSAHSA card
• The hub comes with a 2-year guarantee whereas the components (together with bottles, breast shields, spouts and valves) include a 90-day guarantee
• Might be washed on the highest shelf of your dishwasher
• The suction motion attracts milk out of your breast by way of a breast protect straight into the bottle

Variations:

• The Willow Pump can maintain 4 ounces of milk on both sides whereas the Elvie can maintain 5 ounces of milk on both sides.
• The Willow affords extra flexibility when it comes to what might be finished if you are pumping. The Willow claims which you could pump whereas laying down whereas some customers have stated the Elvie is greatest for utilizing whereas standing, sitting, or doing extra sedentary actions.
•  Willow has particular milk luggage that it’s a must to purchase nevertheless, they launched their reusable milk containers that match straight into the pump as an answer which now’s corresponding to the Elvie. With the Elvie pump, you pump right into a reusable 5oz bottle. The baggage will not be reusable.
• The Willow is often not coated by insurance coverage whereas the Elvie has been recognized to be partially coated by some insurances. Get began by filling out this kind along with your insurance coverage data. Nonetheless, you need to be capable to buy each pumps with an FSAHSA Card.
• The Elvie Pump has 5 components to wash together with the valve, spout, bottle, seal and breast protect. They are often washed within the dishwasher or by hand. The Willow has two components to cleansing together with the flange and a tube that connects to the pump. They’ll additionally each be washed by hand or within the dishwasher.
• Elvie affords a two yr guarantee on the pump and 90 days on the pump components. Willow affords a one yr guarantee.

Similarities

• Each the Willow and Elvie have apps which are obtainable for the iPhone and Android. You’ll be able to obtain them from the app retailer and they’re going to hook up with your pump. With each apps you’ll be able to see how a lot you’ve got pumped.
• Components are dishwasher secure
• Each pumps take about 2 hours to completely cost
• Each can’t be returned as soon as opened
• Each declare to be silent breast pumps
• Each pumps are wi-fi, relaxation in your bra and are in a position for use out and about.
• You’ll be able to regulate the suction ranges on each pumps and so they each sense letdown and change to expression mode.

Which One is Greatest?

Truthfully, each of those pumps are nice palms free pumps. They’re related in value, although with Elvie, you should buy only one, and it could be inexpensive.

From our analysis, girls are very happy with all of those choices. I really feel like that Willow pump is a bit more foremost stream and there are extra tutorials and suggestions for it – plus they appear to have extra particular affords and offers to make it slightly extra reasonably priced (or, you’ll be able to not less than get extra equipment!).

We haven’t been capable of do a facet by facet comparability of the 2 pumps but, however we hope to do this within the close to future. General, although, you actually can’t go fallacious. We advocate going via the professionals and cons, in addition to the options, that we’ve talked about above after which selecting which of these are extra necessary to you!

I’ve heard from some that Elvie misplaced its suction after awhile, so that’s one thing to bear in mind.

In case you’ve tried both of those pumps, please remark beneath! We’d love to listen to your expertise.

BUY WILLOW – WILLOW.COM / AMAZON
BUY ELVIE – ELVIE.COM / AMAZON

Different Posts You Could Get pleasure from:

Katie Clark is an Worldwide Board Licensed Lactation Advisor (IBCLC). She has helped hundreds of moms and households across the globe navigate breastfeeding challenges and questions since 2015. She has a ardour for creating research-based, useful breastfeeding schooling and serving to mother and father discover a option to make breastfeeding work for them. Katie is a mother of three little boys and lives within the nice state of Colorado. She additionally has a level in Communications with an emphasis in print journalism.