A younger North Carolina girl has refused to go to a nursing dwelling in one other state. Whereas she desires to depart the hospital, she asks to dwell in her own residence, near household and her faculty.
MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:
In North Carolina, there’s an 18-year-old girl who has needed to dwell in a hospital since she was 13. Now the hospital is suing her to depart. She desires to dwell some place else, too, however not the place the hospital says. NPR investigative correspondent Joseph Shapiro explains.
JOSEPH SHAPIRO, BYLINE: From her hospital mattress, Alexis Ratcliff asks the query.
ALEXIS RATCLIFF: What 18-year-old will get sued?
SHAPIRO: What 18-year-old will get sued? It is arduous to listen to Alexis. Her voice is delicate and the whoosh of the ventilator, the machine that retains her respiration, is harsh.
(SOUNDBITE OF MACHINE WHOOSHING)
SHAPIRO: Alexis Ratcliff was sued by this very hospital. It desires her to depart.
RATCLIFF: However I did not ask to be right here. It wasn’t my alternative. It wasn’t my determination. I did not wish to be right here. However sadly, I am the one which obtained sued.
SHAPIRO: Alexis is a quadriplegic. She will’t transfer something beneath her neck. That is why she wants that ventilator to push oxygen into her lungs. She got here to this hospital in Winston-Salem, N.C., when she was 18 months previous after a automotive crash. Docs right here saved her life. Her mom was driving that automotive. She was excessive, obtained charged and went to jail. Alexis was despatched dwelling to dwell with different household, however that ended when her grandfather had critical well being issues and moved to an assisted dwelling facility.
So in 2019, on the age of 13, Alexis Ratcliff returned to this hospital, Atrium Well being Wake Forest Baptist. Apart from one six-month break, she’s lived right here ever since. Now the hospital says it is time for her to go. It discovered a mattress for her in a nursing dwelling in one other state. Alexis, who turned her personal guardian when she turned 18 final summer time, mentioned no. The hospital then sued her for trespass.
RATCLIFF: OK, Siri, FaceTime Apple.
SIRI: Beginning a FaceTime name to Apple.
SHAPIRO: Alexis desires to get out of the hospital, too, however to not dwell in a nursing dwelling far-off. Every single day she calls her sister Apple.
RATCLIFF: I guess you cash she’s on the telephone along with her boyfriend.
SHAPIRO: From her hospital mattress, she makes use of her voice to regulate her iPad and iPhone. With know-how like this, Alexis desires to dwell in her own residence or condominium near household.
RATCLIFF: Why do not you play basketball?
APPLE: As a result of I am unable to shoot a basketball in a hoop.
RATCLIFF: Effectively, that is a problem.
SHAPIRO: Alexis will want numerous caregiving assist at dwelling, most likely 24 hours a day – aides to observe that her ventilator works, that her trach tube, which sends air to her lungs, would not get clogged, somebody to maneuver her in mattress and in her wheelchair so she would not get painful stress sores. Nonetheless, care at house is normally cheaper than what it prices for a disabled particular person like Alexis to dwell in that hospital or a nursing dwelling.
RATCLIFF: Love you, bye.
APPLE: Love you, bye.
SHAPIRO: On the hospital, Dr. Kevin Excessive, who till lately was president right here, says this is not about cash – Medicaid pays for Alexis. However a hospital is not a spot for folks to dwell long run. And he says the ICU at Wake Forest Baptist Hospital is already crowded.
KEVIN HIGH: We all the time have folks ready for beds and particularly ICU beds, and we have not had full capability to try this when you could have individuals who keep within the hospital for a really lengthy time frame like this.
SHAPIRO: Alexis says, she nonetheless wants the mattress, too. One factor to notice, since Alexis got here again to the hospital in 2019, the extent of care right here has been glorious – no bedsores, no respiratory infections. These could be frequent and lethal for a quadriplegic on a ventilator. And the nurses, docs and employees have been a few of her greatest supporters and greatest mates.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
SHAPIRO: Final spring, when she graduated highschool, they threw a giant celebration. And in August, when she turned 18, employees on the pediatric facet threw her an excellent larger celebration. The following day, the hospital moved her to the grownup facet of the hospital and upped the stress to drive her to a nursing dwelling it present in Virginia after no nursing dwelling in North Carolina would take her.
LISA NESBITT: However proper now, there isn’t any recognized path again for her if she leaves the state.
SHAPIRO: Lisa Nesbitt is considered one of Alexis’ legal professionals at Incapacity Rights North Carolina. She says if Alexis strikes to a nursing dwelling in one other state, she turns into a citizen of that state and offers up her North Carolina Medicaid. That may make it unlikely she might return to North Carolina. The legal professionals went to courtroom and gained an order that stopped the hospital from instantly shifting Alexis out of state, not less than for now.
JOONU COSTE: She completely can get that care at dwelling.
SHAPIRO: Joonu Coste is one other lawyer at Incapacity Rights North Carolina. She notes that the state of North Carolina despatched aides to assist Alexis when she lived in her grandfather’s dwelling for all these years earlier than she got here again to the hospital.
COSTE: It is all attainable, however Medicaid has to step in and assist put this package deal collectively for her.
SHAPIRO: There’s one other key participant right here, the state Medicaid company. It is accountable, even required by the federal authorities, to assist folks like Alexis Ratcliff get long-term care in their very own properties, not in a hospital or a nursing dwelling. NPR requested to talk to somebody at North Carolina’s Medicaid company about what they’re doing to assist Alexis get out of the hospital. The reply we obtained again? No remark.
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: Alexis Religion Ratcliff.
(CHEERING)
SHAPIRO: Final spring, Alexis graduated from her highschool in a rural county north of Winston-Salem. Alexis and her legal professionals say the hospital warned, if you happen to go away the hospital, we cannot allow you to again in. It took a decide’s order to let her attend commencement. She took courses on-line from her hospital mattress, graduated with honors, made Nationwide Honor Society. She gained a full educational scholarship to school…
(SOUNDBITE OF BELL)
SHAPIRO: …At close by Salem School, a small girls’s faculty with pink brick sidewalks and buildings relationship again to the 1700s. Susan Ratcliff is Alexis’ aunt.
SUSAN RATCLIFF: That is completely one of the stunning locations in Winston-Salem.
SHAPIRO: She meets Alexis’ college adviser, Diane Lipsett.
DIANE LIPSETT: We speak rather a lot right here. All of my colleagues speak about assembly college students the place they’re. Typically that is metaphorical or – however with Alexis, it means a special area, too.
SHAPIRO: When Alexis could not go away the hospital for workplace hours, Lipsett took workplace hours to Alexis in her hospital room. Lipsett and the varsity have labored to make Alexis profitable as a pupil, organising these on-line courses for now and pondering out the way to transfer courses to wheelchair-accessible rooms if Alexis can at some point get on campus. Alexis’ aunt says till she lived within the hospital, Alexis obtained on a bus on daily basis to go to center faculty.
RATCLIFF: She loves folks, and she or he would like to be right here along with her friends. She has missed out on a lot of that.
SHAPIRO: Alexis agrees.
RATCLIFF: Sure, I’m a quad, however I am nonetheless a traditional human being similar to all people else. And I ought to have the ability to dwell life to the fullest of my capability.
SHAPIRO: Now Alexis Ratcliff desires to get out of the hospital, to keep away from the nursing dwelling in one other state, and to maneuver into a spot she will be able to name dwelling.
Joseph Shapiro, NPR Information.
(SOUNDBITE OF COCONUT RECORDS AND WOODY JACKSON’S “DAKOTA”)
Copyright © 2024 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content is probably not in its closing kind and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability might range. The authoritative report of NPR’s programming is the audio report.
Supply hyperlink
